Summary
- Churn dominates. Dutch universities exchanged about 6,500 researchers with the world in 2020 (3,353 in, 3,191 out), roughly 6% of the research workforce, so the net balance is the smallest number in the picture.
- The net turned positive, but only slightly. Scopus shows a deficit of 434 in 2015, +108 in 2019 and +162 in 2020, which is 0.15% of the workforce.
- One corridor explains 2020. The US corridor swung by 160 (from -65 to +95). Without it, the Dutch net fell from +173 in 2019 to +67 in 2020, and a pandemic effect is a plausible explanation.
- Italy and Switzerland deserve more attention. Italy was a net donor every year, but the surplus shrank from +62 to +27. Switzerland pulled a growing net of researchers away, from -16 to -55.
- Two databases disagree on size. For 2018, Scopus shows a net of -35 and OpenAlex shows -221, so the “brain gain” claim rests on one source’s reading of two years.
- Policy is moving but not settled. The Tulip Fund funded 34 researchers, 29 from the US (including returning Europeans), and the bill dropping the English-language test has yet to pass.
- What leaders should do. Target outreach at Italy and the US, fix housing, partner careers and start-up support, track retention by cohort, and watch Germany and Switzerland as competitors.
Background
Dutch universities are among the most open research systems in the world, and the data show it. In 2020, Scopus records 3,353 researchers arriving in the Netherlands and 3,191 leaving, out of about 108,000 active publishing researchers. That is roughly 6,500 moves in a single year, or about 6 percent of the workforce changing country of affiliation.
A tempting headline follows. For years the Netherlands lost more researchers than it gained, with a net deficit of 434 in 2015. In 2019 the balance turned positive (+108), and in 2020 it grew to +162. Add the US research funding cuts, the Dutch Tulip Fund, and a new coalition that has reversed course on English-taught programmes, and the story writes itself: the Netherlands moved from brain drain to brain gain.
I think that story is too neat. This post sets out what the data support, what they do not, and what I would do about it as someone running or advising an institution.






